MiniMania.com
NEED HELP?

Currency: 
 Product Search
Using Synthetic-Will it run cooler ?
TOPIC:  

Using Synthetic-Will it run cooler ?

    Created by: ve9aa
Orig. Posting Date User Name Edit Date Msg No.
Jun-22-2008 02:44PM xcc_rider   847248
Jun-22-2008 02:11PM kerr   847243
Jun-22-2008 01:49PM mini_fly   847237
Jun-21-2008 04:43PM kerr Edited: Jun-21-2008 05:26PM   847085
Jun-21-2008 04:33PM ve9aa   847080
Jun-21-2008 01:52AM 1963S   846950
Jun-21-2008 12:32AM Alex   846947
Jun-20-2008 10:13PM MacDhaibhidh   846922
Jun-20-2008 06:16PM BOBB   846873
Jun-20-2008 04:59PM kd   846864
Jun-20-2008 03:08PM xcc_rider   846837
Jun-20-2008 02:39PM ve9aa Edited: Jun-20-2008 02:45PM   846833
Jun-20-2008 02:34PM BRG Mini   846831
Jun-20-2008 02:29PM bluedragon   846829
Jun-20-2008 01:45PM geoO   846821
Jun-20-2008 01:34PM Cup Cake   846817
Jun-20-2008 01:19PM ve9aa   846813

 Forum Width:     Forum Type: 
Found 17 Messages   Page 1 of 1:   1 
Login Topic List
 Posted: Jun-22-2008 02:44PM
xcc_rider
Total Posts: 1099
Last Post: 12-02-08
Member Since: 10-06-04

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply

Yep, I'd check it just to see what it is at idle and then at the prescribed max mechanical advance rpm for your distributor. You can check Marcel's website for your distributor type and serial number and it will tell you what the advance will be at the max rpm and go from there.

I haven't done this yet but can you imagine what my mechanical advanced timing was when the idle timing was 38 deg BTDC?  I think I set a new record. 

Check it out and let us know what you find.  dan

"I don't know much, but what I do know I know little of "

 Posted: Jun-22-2008 02:11PM
kerr
Total Posts: 
Last Post: 12-03-08
Member Since: 03-13-00

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply
no, the best way to do it is to use a timing light that has a dial on it to adjust when it flashes.

With one of those you can accurately measure the advance against the "TDC" mark, no matter how high the advance finally goes. You read the advance on the timing light instead of on the engine (just turn the knob until the pulley mark is lined up with the TDC mark and then read what the knob is set to).

I learned my lesson the hard way, don't bother with a static timing light, buy a light with that adjustment instead.

Norm

 Posted: Jun-22-2008 01:49PM
mini_fly
Total Posts: 867
Last Post: 11-17-08
Member Since: 06-25-02

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply

How can you tell what it is over 20 degrees when the scale only goes to 20?  The scale at the timing cover is not exactly linear.

Do you have to gestimate?

 Posted: Jun-21-2008 04:43PM
 Edited:  Jun-21-2008 05:26PM
kerr
Total Posts: 
Last Post: 12-03-08
Member Since: 03-13-00

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply
well, it sounds like we found your problem: the distributor is stuck and you don't know if the timing is right. Your overheating at high speeds is classic timing over-advance.

When you do check your timing, be sure to check it at high RPM (4000RPM, or so, should get you to full advance, check your shop manual, though, to be sure, because max advance was set anywhere from 2600 ~ 7000 RPM, depending on the year your engine/dizzy was built).

what you want to see at full advance will depend on your engine set-up, and the Morris/Austin/BL/Rover shop manual is a great resource because they said what it should be at several RPMs, and what the maximum advance should be.

Unfortunately, Haynes doesn't say anything about maximum advance, and Vizard's book on tuning the A series talks about how important it is, but doesn't supply much real information on what it should be. I don't know why. One rule of thumb is that after you add up the advance at idle, plus the full mechanical advance, and you should never go above 40 degrees (I can't find this written anywhere, I just have a note from what an old timer told me once when I was struggling with an issue with a car that was running over-advanced at high RPM and overheating). So, the amount of total mechanical advance should not be above 30deg, as a rough rule of thumb.

Depending on the year, and displacement of the A series engine, mech. advance has been anywhere from 26 ~ 36deg.

Of course, all of the above must be done with the vacuum advance disconnected from the vacuum source.

Seeing the wide array of advance curves used over the years, it is clearer than ever how valuable a resource something like the 123 distributor is, to be able to dial right in to what your own engine can most make use of, on a proper rolling road dynamometer.

Let us know how it turns out.

Norm

 Posted: Jun-21-2008 04:33PM
ve9aa
Total Posts: 6406
Last Post: 12-02-08
Member Since: 09-30-02

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply

I loosened the bolt @ the base of my dizzy ~2 years ago when I first got the car and after trying numerous tools, I ended up putting a vice grip (locking pliers) on it and with all my 200lbs was unable to turn the thing.  Any more force, and I will quite literally break the dizzy off the engine, so I hadn't even taken the next step to even CHECK the timing, but maybe I should at least see what it is.

It only heats up on extended runs on the highway in excess of, let's say, 50mph/90km/h.  I can putt putt around town or do 30-50mph all day and it usually doesn't get hot.

I do have plenty of dampener oil in the top of the carb, and don't think my antifreeze mixture is too rich.

No time to play with it at all today. Was outside yankin' heavy stuff out of the woods with the Land Rover and mowing lotsa grass all day today.

Maybe tomorrow if time permits !

Thanks guys.  Appreciate the suggestions.

 

Who wants to buy my Series II 88"-Land Rover so I can buy Alex's "BETTY" ? 

       ~ 30 minutes in a Mini is more therapeutic than 3 sessions @ the shrink. ~

     Mike  NB, Canada   

 Posted: Jun-21-2008 01:52AM
1963S
Total Posts: 434
Last Post: 12-01-08
Member Since: 09-21-06

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply
Spare heater element (or bike rad) spliced into coolant line between heater tap (clutch end of head) and bottom rad hose should solve a cooling problem.

If it works in Oz it should be adequate in Canada.....

Cheers, Ian

 Posted: Jun-21-2008 12:32AM
Alex
Total Posts: 5828
Last Post: 11-30-08
Member Since: 03-24-99

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply
What antifreeze mix are you running ?
Too much antifreeze and all the water-wetter in the world won't help...

Checking timing at 4000rpm - is that with the vac advance on or off ?

Metric is for people who can't do fractions.

 Posted: Jun-20-2008 10:13PM
MacDhaibhidh
Total Posts: 1608
Last Post: 11-30-08
Member Since: 04-04-01

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply
Mine is at 28 degree's, also check your Air fuel with a colortune.

Thank You in advance!

Stieve

Grumpy: I'm bettin' The Joker told you to kill me soon as we loaded the cash.
BOZO;The Joker: No no no no, I kill the bus driver.
Grumpy: Bus driver? What bus driver?

 Posted: Jun-20-2008 06:16PM
BOBB
Total Posts: 2879
Last Post: 11-27-08
Member Since: 01-13-01

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply
As KD said no more than 30!!!!!!   BOBB

 Posted: Jun-20-2008 04:59PM
kd
Total Posts: 680
Last Post: 12-01-08
Member Since: 03-09-00

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply

Hey Mike, Keith thinks that your timing is wrong. First I'll say that we run all our vehicules on Mobil 1 Synthetic.

We also use Water Wetter and DOT 5 synthetic brake fluid. 

Check your timing at 4000 rpm.  It should  be between 26 and 30 degrees. 

No more. IF it is more you have to find a way to get your dissy to move.

Deb 

Keith & Deb

Avatar:Turn 1 at the Glen

 Posted: Jun-20-2008 03:08PM
xcc_rider
Total Posts: 1099
Last Post: 12-02-08
Member Since: 10-06-04

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply

I think I learned the hard way that timing has alot to do with engine temperature. After procrastinating for 2 1/2 years, fitting a super 2-core, tropical fan, water wetter it still ran very, very hot on the freeway. High rpms and excessive heat, really bad up around 90 deg outside temp.

Well, I finally got around to checking the timing and found it was somewhere in the 35-38 BTDC range at 600(ish) rpm. No pinging or performance issues with the extremely advanced setting. With Doug's help (thx again) I've made my own timing marks (no marks on the flywheel), timing pointer and have been playing around with the timing and have lowered it to 20 BTDC with dramatic results. I took a run today in 100 deg heat, off and on the freeway and it ran cooler than ever! 185F on the freeway, up and down hills (until I hit the monster incline and it went up to 200F but not any higher). I couldn't even drive city streets when it was over 90F without it REALLY getting hot. Lowered it to 17.5BTDC and will drive again to see what difference it makes and gradually work it down to the "normal" setting.

So I guess the moral of this is check your timing and see what it is, if it is too far advanced, free up the distributor, time it correctly and see what happens.

Now that I was soooooo long winded, if it doesn't overheat on country roads or city driving it could also be running lean at freeway rpms so check the dampener oil, spring(s) and last but not least try a richer profile needle for the top end rpms.  dan

"I don't know much, but what I do know I know little of "

 Posted: Jun-20-2008 02:39PM
 Edited:  Jun-20-2008 02:45PM
ve9aa
Total Posts: 6406
Last Post: 12-02-08
Member Since: 09-30-02

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply

I'm running water wetter, heater is always on (but fan not always blowing-obviously), but haven't checked the vacuum on the dizzy in a looong while though - good tip, thanks !

Willy: Yeah, whodathunkit? ;-)

Who wants to buy my Series II 88"-Land Rover so I can buy Alex's "BETTY" ? 

       ~ 30 minutes in a Mini is more therapeutic than 3 sessions @ the shrink. ~

     Mike  NB, Canada   

 Posted: Jun-20-2008 02:34PM
BRG Mini
Total Posts: 5762
Last Post: 12-02-08
Member Since: 04-13-03

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply

Minis run hot in Canada??? 

willy

 Posted: Jun-20-2008 02:29PM
bluedragon
Total Posts: 646
Last Post: 12-02-08
Member Since: 01-28-05

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply

Many synthetics have ZDDP. Shell Rotella-T, Redline - like regular oil, ZDDP is an additive and you have to look at the "ingredients" for each brand you are considering.

The "SL" or earlier diesel oils should have sufficient levels of zinc (Rotella-T is Shells' diesel/Truck synthetic.) "SM" is the class of oil with low zinc levels.

I am not sure that synthetic is going to make that big a difference though. Its main attribute as far as temperature is concerned, is that it can stand higher temperatures before breaking down. I have read some cases recording a 10°F drop, but I think that would be an exceptional result. The stability and consistency of synthetic is what makes it great for cold weather starting. It doesn't thicken as much in cold temperatures, and it doesn't thin out as readily at high temperatures.

If the seals on the car are relatively new (no more than a few years old) I don't think you should have a leakage problem. My Mini uses synthetic and leaks very little (and it leaked before I used synthetic.) The rumor is that really old motors will have lots of gunk that helps old gaskets seal, and synthetic's cleaning powers will loosen the gunk and make them leak. So if your motor has old seals, then there may be a risk there.

 

 

DLY

 Posted: Jun-20-2008 01:45PM
geoO
Total Posts: 724
Last Post: 11-15-08
Member Since: 01-01-05

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply
Some people think Water Wetter (a Red Line product) makes 'em run cooler. And don't forget to turn on your heater as a second radiator. And make sure you don't have a vacuum leak between the dizzy and the intake. I did, and boy did it run hot until I found and fixed that.

And to answer one of your specifics, if you DO use synthetic, then only top up with synthetic.

 Posted: Jun-20-2008 01:34PM
Cup Cake
Total Posts: 5570
Last Post: 12-03-08
Member Since: 05-13-01

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply
My perference based on nothing more than that is not to use synthetic because the oil also lubricates the transmission. I don't think synthetic has ZDDP in it either which is required by flat-top followers.

 Posted: Jun-20-2008 01:19PM
ve9aa
Total Posts: 6406
Last Post: 12-02-08
Member Since: 09-30-02

 
Topic List Quote Reply Reply

Tried all/most/some of the usual things to have my car run cool, but on the highway, eventually the temp guage will creep up and up.  No time to make any actual mods to the car, so, oil is my last hope.  Car runs rich-ish, so not a lean-out problem.  Dizzy will NOT move/rotate.  (have tried everything-gotta be welded in there) so can't vary the timing, though it for sure is not pinging.(advanced) and always seems to start/run well.  Engine 1970's vintage A-series 998, nearly bone stock with stage 1.

One of the guys at work has put Amsoil, synthetic in his Honda ST-1300A bike and swears it runs cooler now, as compared to before, and comparing it on runs with another guy running the identical bike.

Will using Synthetic in my Mini make it run cooler? (even a little?) How bad are my oil leaks gonna be on the garage floor if I switch?  I should change the oil before going to Maine/MME in a week or so.  Will I be able to top up with "regular" oil, and does it HAVE to be synthetic? So many questions.  The only experience I have with synthetic is when I switched my OLD vw Golf diesel over one winter, and noticed it started (rolled over) much quicker.

And, no, I haven't yet done a searchback 365.  yes, I should've known better before asking.

Who wants to buy my Series II 88"-Land Rover so I can buy Alex's "BETTY" ? 

       ~ 30 minutes in a Mini is more therapeutic than 3 sessions @ the shrink. ~

     Mike  NB, Canada   

Found 17 Messages   Page 1 of 1:   1 
Mini Cooper Part-MTMINI-B1 VTEC B2 SERIES AXLE UPGRADE Upgrade your standard MTB2 axle shaft to these completed axles with brand new inner and outer CV Joints! When you choose to upgrade to this kit, we will build your axles using the new inner and outer [ More Info]

List Price: $375.00

On SALE: $345.10
 
 
Mini Cooper Part-MTSTR2 VTEC POLY MOUNT KIT,BLACK FOR (DC) CHASSIS,3 HOLES HONDA

List Price: $195.00

On SALE: $175.50
 
 
Mini Cooper Part-MOTR7010 MINI COOPER EURO PLATE PLAQUE LICENSE PLATE A plastic 'MINI Cooper' Euro Plate. Use this for a wall decoration in your office or garage! 4 1/4" BY 20 1/2" LONG Limited to stock on hand.

List Price: $39.95

On CLEARANCE: $20.00
 
 
Mini Cooper Part-MT20300 FRONT END HINGE KIT FOR FIBERGLASS FRONT END VTEC This unique hinge kit allows you to adapt either a stock fiberglass front end or one that is lengenthened for a Vtec conversion for easy access to the front of the car. Several people have used this [ More Info]

List Price: $199.95

On SALE: $175.00
 
 
 
copyright © 2008 MiniMania.com